H11

​‌​​‌​

H11 / AMS 6487 / AMS 6437

H11
UNS T20811 · W.Nr. 1.2343 · EN ISO 4957 X37CrMoV5-1 (former DIN name X38CrMoV5-1) · JIS SKD6 · BS BH11 · ~5% Cr – 1.3% Mo – 0.4% V – C ~0.37%. THIS IS A 5% CHROMIUM HOT WORK TOOL STEEL. EN ISO 4957 band (1.2343): C 0.33-0.41% – Si 0.80-1.20% – Mn 0.25-0.50% – Cr 4.80-5.50% – Mo 1.10-1.50% – V 0.30-0.50% – P 0.030% max – S 0.020% max. The ASTM A681 / AISI H11 band is NOT THE SAME: C 0.33-0.43% – Mn 0.20-0.50/0.60% – Si 0.80-1.20/1.25% – Cr 4.75-5.50% – Mo 1.10-1.60% – V 0.30-0.60%. The two bands do not overlap at the carbon ceiling (EN 0.41%, ASTM 0.43%) or the vanadium ceiling (EN 0.50%, ASTM 0.60%); material certified to 1.2343 is therefore not automatically acceptable against an ASTM A681 H11 order. AEROSPACE H-11 (AMS 6487 / 6437) IS A THIRD BAND: C 0.38-0.43%, nominally 5.0Cr – 1.3Mo – 0.50V; AMS 6487 additionally requires CONSUMABLE ELECTRODE VACUUM RE-MELTING (CEVM/VAR). IT IS NOT STAINLESS. It does NOT precipitation harden; there is NO ageing step of the H900 / H1025 / H1150 type. The hardening route is: austenitise – harden in air, oil or a salt bath – DOUBLE (preferably TRIPLE) TEMPER. The tempering curve shows SECONDARY HARDENING: hardness rises again around 450-510 °C.
Not to be confused with

AISI 4140

For what
It is bought for two distinct jobs, and one material quality does not serve both. (1) HOT WORK TOOLING: die casting dies, forging dies, extrusion tooling (liners, stems, container mantles, pressure pads, mandrels, die holders), hot shear blades, hot punches and plastic injection moulds – work in…
Forms
Round bar · flat bar · plate · sheet · pipe/tube · forgings. All forms are supplied to order. NOTE: AMS coverage splits by form – AMS 6487 covers bars, forgings and forging stock only, AMS 6437 covers sheet, strip and plate only, and no verified H-11 AMS number was found for tube (see the standards map).
Standards
AMS (ACTIVE, verified one by one): 6487 – ‘Steel, Bars, Forgings, and Forging Stock 5.0Cr – 1.3Mo – 0.50V (0.38 – 0.43C) (H-11) Consumable Electrode Vacuum Re-Melted’, premium aircraft quality, current revision M/2021 (revision N is work in progress at SAE) · 6437 – ‘Steel, Sheet, Strip, and Plate, 5.0Cr – 1.3Mo – 0.50V (0.38 – 0.43C) (H-11), Aircraft Quality’, current revision L/2025 (previous K/2020). AMS (CANCELLED – NOT TO BE PUT ON AN ORDER): 6485H/1989 ‘Steel Bars and Forgings, 5.0Cr 1.3Mo 0.50V (0.38-0.43C)’ – CANCELLED October 2006, superseded by AMS 6487 · 6488H ‘Steel, Bars and Forgings 5.0Cr 1.3Mo 0.50V (0.38-0.43C)’ (premium quality) – CANCELLED January 2008; the ANSI record carries the note that ‘similar but not necessarily identical products are covered in AMS 6487‘. ASTM: A681 – ‘Standard Specification for Tool Steels Alloy’; its scope covers hot or cold finished bar, plate, sheet, strip, rod, wire and forgings. EN / ISO: EN ISO 4957:2018 ‘Tool steels’ (ISO 4957:2018, 3rd edition, 2018-06) – 1.2343 / X37CrMoV5-1. OTHER NATIONAL: JIS G4404 SKD6 · BS 4659 BH11. INDUSTRY: NADCA #207 acceptance and heat treat criteria (the BÖHLER W300 ISOBLOC page carries the NADCA D1830 / #207 designation).
TOOL STEEL H11 AND AEROSPACE H-11 ARE NOT THE SAME THING. The difference sits at three points:
1) CARBON BAND. The ASTM A681 H11 band is C 0.33-0.43%; the band in the AMS 6487 and AMS 6437 titles is C 0.38-0.43%.
Advantage
Its single most important practical advantage is SECONDARY HARDENING: as the tempering temperature rises, hardness first falls and then RISES AGAIN. The curve Lucefin measured on a specimen oil quenched from 1020 °C is: 52 HRC at 250 °C, 53.5 HRC at 350 °C, 55.5 HRC at 450 °C and 56 HRC at 510 °C.
Welding
IT IS WELDABLE, BUT A HIGH PREHEAT IS MANDATORY, and the delivery condition of the part governs the welding decision. PREHEAT: the BÖHLER tool welding handbook gives 350-400 °C for the 1.2343 / W300 class in the soft annealed condition and 400-450 °C in the hardened condition.
Limits
1) IT IS NOT STAINLESS. Chromium is 4.75-5.50%, which is not enough to form a passive layer. Without oil, plating or another protective measure it rusts in damp air; it is not suitable for marine or chloride-bearing environments.
Compiled from manufacturer data sheets · confirm against the current specification before ordering

​‌​​‌​

On this page · click to jump
What AISI H11 IsH11 versus H13Standards by Product FormCode Acceptance and Temperature CeilingsProduct Forms With NO StandardChemical CompositionHeat TreatmentPremium Aircraft Quality H11 (AMS 6487)Mechanical PropertiesPhysical PropertiesThermal Fatigue (Heat Checking) ResistanceWeldingMachining and EDMCorrosion and WHERE IT FAILSFrequently Asked Questions



H11 is a medium-alloy chromium steel that comes from the hot-work tool steel class but is used for aerospace structural parts. Within the alloy steel group it stands out for retaining its strength at high temperature; its UNS designation is T20811.

The defining property of this material is that it retains most of its strength of approximately 1900 MPa up to 538 °C. The 5% chromium provides hot hardness and scaling resistance, while the 1.3% molybdenum and 0.5% vanadium provide temper resistance and fine grain. Limiting the carbon content to 0.40% helps preserve toughness at this strength level.​‌​​‌​

Heat treatment: austenitise at 1010 °C for 15-45 minutes and air cool, then temper in three stages of 2-3 hours each at 538 °C and above, air cooling between stages. Tempering three times completes the transformation of retained austenite and so gives dimensional stability.

It is used in aircraft structural parts, particularly landing gear components. It is supplied as round bar.​‌​​‌​

Chemical Composition · H11

C — Carbon​‌​​‌​0.40%
Mn — Manganese​‌​​‌​0.30%
Si — Silicon​‌​​‌​0.90%
Cr — Chromium​‌​​‌​5.00%
Mo — Molybdenum​‌​​‌​1.30%
V — Vanadium​‌​​‌​0.50%
Fe — Iron​‌​​‌​Balance
Mechanical Properties · H11
​‌​​‌​

Tensile strength Rm1793 MPa​‌​​‌​
Yield strength Rp0.21482 MPa​‌​​‌​
Elongation8%​‌​​‌​
Reduction of area30%​‌​​‌​
Standards and Equivalents · H11

Trade name​‌​​‌​H11
AMS​‌​​‌​6485 · 6487
Available forms​‌​​‌​Round bar · Flat bar · Plate · Sheet · Tube · Forgings
All forms are supplied to order.

→ Contact us for H11 stock availability, sizes and AMS 6487 / AMS 6437 certified supply.​‌​​‌​

Request a quote

​‌​​‌​

What AISI H11 Is — and Why It Has Two Separate Lives

AISI H11 (UNS T20811 / W.Nr. 1.2343 / EN X37CrMoV5-1) is a 5 % chromium, air-hardening hot-work tool steel: nominally 0.38 C – 5.0 Cr – 1.3 Mo – 0.4 V – 1.0 Si. Medium carbon plus high chromium plus molybdenum delivers three things at once: deep air hardening, secondary hardening (hardness rising again during tempering) and strength retention at elevated temperature.​‌​​‌​

The one number that defines H11 is vanadium: 0.30–0.60 %. In its sibling H13 the same band is 0.80–1.20 %. Everything else — carbon, chromium, molybdenum, silicon — is effectively identical. That half-point of vanadium turns two steels into two different commercial products, and that is the most important section on this page.

H11’s little-known second life is this: the same steel, bought to AMS 6487 premium aircraft quality, is used not as a tool steel but as an ultra-high-strength STRUCTURAL steel — landing gear, rocket motor cases, critical fasteners. Carpenter’s own wording is explicit: strength in excess of 260,000 psi and high creep and rupture strength between 427 and 649 °C (800–1200 °F). Same chemistry, same heat-treatment logic, entirely different purchasing specification and entirely different inspection regime. It is opened up in its own section below.​‌​​‌​

Honest Positioning Inside the Hot-Work Tool Steel Family

AISI H11
(T20811 / 1.2343 / X37CrMoV5-1)​‌​​‌​
5 Cr – 1.3 Mo – 0.4 V. The family’s TOUGHNESS grade. Low vanadium = fewer hard carbides = fewer crack initiators = better toughness and better heat-checking (thermal fatigue) resistance. The price: lower wear resistance. Its near-1 % silicon also gives it good resistance to wetting and soldering by molten aluminium
AISI H13
(T20813 / 1.2344 / X40CrMoV5-1)​‌​​‌​
5 Cr – 1.4 Mo – 1.0 V. The family’s WEAR grade and the world standard. Vanadium carbides raise hardness and wear resistance and improve hot hardness somewhat. The price: lower transverse toughness and a little more sensitivity to heat checking. It is the de facto default for aluminium die casting and it sits at the centre of the NADCA acceptance criteria
AISI H10
(1.2365 / 32CrMoV12-28)​‌​​‌​
Lower chromium (~3 %), higher molybdenum (~2.8 %), with cobalt-bearing derivatives. Higher hot strength, but a different balance of toughness and heat checking. Used on brass and copper extrusion dies and in hot forging
AISI H21
(1.2581 / X30WCrV9-3)​‌​​‌​
A tungsten-based hot-work steel. A different chemistry from the chromium-molybdenum family. Much higher hot hardness, but much lower toughness and heat-checking resistance, and it cannot be water cooled. Hot extrusion mandrels, brass dies, high-temperature but low-thermal-shock work
“Premium” / “Superior” H13
(NADCA classes)​‌​​‌​
Not a different chemistry but a different CLEANLINESS and heat-treatment regime: VAR production, sulphur down to about 0.001 %, tight grain size, an annealed hardness ceiling and a mandatory impact toughness test. Same ASTM grade, completely different product
Modified H11, e.g. the Uddeholm Vidar Superior type​‌​​‌​Nominally 0.36 C – 0.3 Si – 0.3 Mn – 5.0 Cr – 1.3 Mo – 0.5 V. Note: silicon has been cut from 1.0 to 0.3 — this is a different steel from classic 1.2343, and the producer describes it openly as offering “significant improvements in impact toughness compared to material of the H11 (1.2343) type”. Its room-temperature Charpy V is of the order of 80–100 J — set that against the 13.6–33.9 J published for classic H11 and the size of the gap becomes clear. Saying “I bought H11” does not say which H11 you bought
AMS 6487 H11
(premium aircraft quality)​‌​​‌​
The same ASTM family, but with the carbon band narrowed to 0.38–0.43 and vacuum consumable electrode remelting (VAR) made mandatory. Sold as a structural steel, not as a die steel. See the dedicated section below

H11 versus H13 — Vanadium at 0.4 % against 1.0 %​‌​​‌​

This is the most important section on an H11 page, and almost no distributor page gets it right. The difference is concentrated in one element and one band, and once the mechanism is understood the commercial consequence follows on its own.

One Difference, Three Consequences

​‌​​‌​

The chemical differenceVanadium: 0.30–0.60 % in H11, 0.80–1.20 % in H13. The carbon, chromium, molybdenum and silicon bands effectively overlap. The whole family splits in two on the doubling of a single element​‌​​‌​
The mechanismDuring tempering, vanadium precipitates very fine, very hard MC-type vanadium carbides. They do three things: (1) they raise the secondary hardening peak; (2) they pin austenite grains and suppress grain growth; (3) they create hard, brittle, angular second-phase particles inside the matrix. The first two are what you want; the third is what you pay​‌​​‌​
Consequence 1 · WearH13 wins. MC carbides are far harder than the matrix; abrasive and erosive wear resistance comes straight from them. Erosion by molten aluminium, die-orifice wear in hot extrusion, dimensional loss in hot forging — H13 is better at all of them​‌​​‌​
Consequence 2 · ToughnessH11 wins. Every hard carbide is a stress raiser and a potential crack initiator. Halve the vanadium and the carbide volume fraction drops; fracture toughness, and above all TRANSVERSE toughness, rises. In heavy sections and shock-loaded applications that difference is decisive​‌​​‌​
Consequence 3 · Heat checking (thermal fatigue)This is the commercially MOST important consequence, and the sources DIVERGE here. The classic tool-steel position: a thermal fatigue crack starts at a stress raiser on the surface; with low carbide volume fraction and high toughness, H11 resists both initiation and propagation better — which is why H11 is preferred on water-cooled dies and under severe thermal shock. The counter-position: some current commercial sources argue that H13’s higher hot hardness and surface yield strength make it more thermal-fatigue resistant. Both cannot be true at once, and no single peer-reviewed dataset measuring the two side by side was found in this study. The honest statement is: low vanadium → high toughness → resistance to crack INITIATION and PROPAGATION; high vanadium → high hot hardness → resistance to plastic flow at the surface. Which one wins depends on how your die is dying​‌​​‌​
Consequence 4 · Annealability and machinabilityFewer hard carbides means a less abrasive material from the cutting tool’s point of view. H11 is a little kinder than H13 in roughing — but both sit in the published 75–80 % band (relative to 1 % carbon steel) and the difference is small in practice​‌​​‌​
The buyer’s decision ruleIf the die is dying by a network of heat-check cracks (fine crazing, water cooled, severe cycling) → go toward H11. If the die is dying by wear (dimensional loss, rounded edges, erosive washout) → go toward H13. If the die is dying by breaking in one go (large crack, corner break-out) → you have a toughness problem: H11 plus a lower working hardness plus a better cleanliness class. Changing grade without reading the failure mode is paying the same money twice​‌​​‌​

Standards by Product Form

​‌​​‌​

STANDARDS BY PRODUCT FORM

Product formStandards
Round bar · flat bar​‌​​‌​AMS 6487 (bars, forgings and forging stock; H-11; CONSUMABLE ELECTRODE VACUUM RE-MELTED; premium aircraft quality; current revision M/2021) · ASTM A681 ‘Standard Specification for Tool Steels Alloy’ · EN ISO 4957:2018 (1.2343 / X37CrMoV5-1) · JIS G4404 SKD6 · BS 4659 BH11. CANCELLED, NOT TO BE PUT ON AN ORDER: AMS 6485 (cancelled October 2006) and AMS 6488 (cancelled January 2008).
Forgings · forging stock​‌​​‌​AMS 6487 (bars, forgings and forging stock; CEVM/VAR required) · ASTM A681 (forgings are within scope) · EN ISO 4957:2018 (1.2343).
Plate · sheet · strip​‌​​‌​AMS 6437 (sheet, strip and plate; H-11; AIRCRAFT QUALITY; current revision L/2025, previous K/2020) · ASTM A681 (plate, sheet and strip are within scope) · EN ISO 4957:2018 (1.2343). NOTE: the AMS 6437 title says ‘Aircraft Quality’ but DOES NOT say ‘Consumable Electrode Vacuum Re-Melted’; it DOES NOT carry the melting requirement of 6487.
Wire rod · wire​‌​​‌​ASTM A681 (rod and wire are within scope) · EN ISO 4957:2018 (1.2343). Carpenter also lists H11 in wire form in its own product list. NO VERIFIED AMS NUMBER WAS FOUND FOR H11 WIRE.
Pipe / tube​‌​​‌​Ordered to the ASTM A681 and EN ISO 4957 chemistry. NO VERIFIED H-11 AMS NUMBER WAS FOUND FOR THIS FORM, and the ASTM A681 scope text does not list tube either (scope: bar, plate, sheet, strip, rod, wire, forgings).
Die casting dies (acceptance and heat treatment)​‌​​‌​NADCA #207 – ‘Special Quality Die Steel & Heat Treatment Acceptance Criteria for Die Casting Dies’. Its requirements: austenitise at 1030 ± 5 °C · minimum 28 °C/minute cooling between 1030 and 540 °C · A MINIMUM OF TWO tempering cycles, the first at 565 °C minimum for at least 2 hours · 1 hour per 25.4 mm with a 2 hour minimum in each cycle · no pearlite, retained austenite, decarburization, carburization or excessive intergranular precipitation in the hardened microstructure. The BÖHLER W300 ISOBLOC product carries the NADCA D1830 / #207 designation.
Welding filler metal​‌​​‌​NO VERIFIED AMS WELDING WIRE NUMBER WAS FOUND FOR H11. The BÖHLER tool welding handbook lists UTP 73 G2 / 73 G3 / 73 G4 for the 1.2343 class; the general rule is that the filler should approximate the chemistry and hardness of the base metal (Ellwood, Total Materia).
Welding procedure group​‌​​‌​NO ASME SECTION IX P-NUMBER IS STATED: H11 is not listed as an ASME BPVC base metal and no P-Number could be verified across four independent sources.
THE AMS NUMBERS SPLIT BY PRODUCT FORM AND DO NOT SUBSTITUTE FOR ONE ANOTHER. AMS 6487 covers bars, forgings and forging stock only; AMS 6437 covers sheet, strip and plate only. AMS 6487 AND AMS 6437 DO NOT CARRY THE SAME CLEANLINESS REQUIREMENT. The 6487 title says ‘Consumable Electrode Vacuum Re-Melted’ and the ANSI record describes the material as ‘premium aircraft-quality’; the 6437 title says only ‘Aircraft Quality’. AMS 6485 AND AMS 6488 HAVE BEEN CANCELLED (October 2006 and January 2008 respectively). Those numbers still appear on distributor pages; they are not a basis for ordering. The ANSI record says AMS 6485 is superseded by AMS 6487, and for AMS 6488 that ‘similar but not necessarily identical products are covered in AMS 6487’. ASTM A681 AND EN ISO 4957 IMPOSE NO MELTING PRACTICE. ESR (electroslag remelted) quality is not a requirement of those standards but a producer’s commercial upgrade (BGH, ROVALMA, Marks and Saglam Metal all offer 1.2343 ESR/ESU). The VAR/CEVM requirement asked for in aerospace work exists only in AMS 6487.

​‌​​‌​

H11’s standards map is split in two and the split matters on the order line: the tooling side (ASTM A681, EN ISO 4957, NADCA) and the aerospace structural side (AMS). Same steel, two acceptance regimes. Each row below states which world it belongs to.

Standards by Product Form · AISI H11 (T20811 / 1.2343)

​‌​​‌​

Bar · flats · squares · blocks · forgings — tooling sideASTM A681 — Standard Specification for Tool Steels Alloy. H11 sits in the hot-work (H series) section. It defines composition and general requirements; it imposes no cleanliness class and no impact toughness requirement​‌​​‌​
Europe · tool steelsEN ISO 4957 — tool steels. The relevant grade is 1.2343 / X37CrMoV5-1. Its composition band OVERLAPS ASTM A681 H11 BUT IS NOT IDENTICAL TO IT — see the chemistry section​‌​​‌​
Bar · forgings · forging stock — aerospace, VAR mandatoryAMS 6487 — full title: Steel, Bars, Forgings, and Forging Stock, 5.0Cr – 1.3Mo – 0.50V (0.38 – 0.43C) (H-11), Consumable Electrode Vacuum Re-Melted (current revision AMS 6487M, 2021). This is the ONLY valid specification for H11’s aerospace structural use​‌​​‌​
AMS 6485 — CAUTIONSteel Bars and Forgings, 5.0Cr – 1.3Mo – 0.50V (0.38–0.43C). This specification has been CANCELLED (rev. H, 1989; cancelled October 2006). It is still listed as live on dozens of datasheets. Do not cite it on a new order​‌​​‌​
AMS 6488 — CAUTIONSteel, Bars and Forgings 5.0Cr – 1.3Mo – 0.50V (0.38–0.43C). This one has been CANCELLED too (rev. H, 1998; cancelled January 2008). A datasheet still listing AMS 6485 and 6488 has not been updated in at least fifteen years​‌​​‌​
Die-casting acceptance criteriaNADCA #207 — Special Quality Die Steel & Heat Treatment Acceptance Criteria for Die Casting Dies. This is not a material specification but an ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA document: annealed hardness ceiling, microcleanliness, annealed microstructure, grain size, a mandatory impact toughness test and heat-treatment requirements. H13 sits at its centre; alternative and premium grades are covered in NADCA #229. H11’s exact standing in those documents could not be independently verified in this study — one producer page uses the designation NADCA D1830 for 1.2343/H11, but that is single-sourced​‌​​‌​
Other national designationsJIS SKD6 · BS BH11 · GOST grades of the 4Kh5MFS type. (One source gives the DIN equivalent as X38CrMoV5-1 — that usually circulates as an older or alternative designation of 1.2343; X37CrMoV5-1 is the current EN name)​‌​​‌​
Welding consumablesThere is NO AWS classification in H11 chemistry. Die repair welding uses either matching wire drawn to the base metal chemistry or, in non-critical areas, a more ductile nickel/stainless-based wire — both to the producer’s procedure​‌​​‌​
ASME Section IX P/F-No.H11 is a tool steel; it is not listed as a pressure-boundary material in the ASME boiler and pressure vessel world. No P-No. assignment could be verified in this study; do not publish a P number​‌​​‌​
Plate · sheet · pipe · fittings · flangesNone, and none should be expected. H11 is not a vessel material​‌​​‌​

Code Acceptance and Temperature Ceilings — the Honest Answer

​‌​​‌​

HEAT TREATMENT — SCHEMATIC

1 · HOT WORKING / FORGING
Step​‌​​‌​1 · HOT WORKING / FORGING
Summary​‌​​‌​Not a heat treatment but a precondition: the forging finish temperature and the cooling that follows decide whether a soft anneal is needed.
Temperature​‌​​‌​The sources diverge. AZoM (ASM-derived) gives 1121 °C (2050 °F) and states that forging below 899 °C is inadvisable. No single numerical band was confirmed across four independent sources, so NO BINDING BAND IS STATED.
Time​‌​​‌​Until the whole section is at temperature. No numerical time was found across four independent sources, so none is stated.
Cooling​‌​​‌​Slow cooling after forging, followed by a soft anneal, is recommended.
Resulting hardness​‌​​‌​No binding hardness is stated for this step.
​‌​​‌​

2 · SOFT ANNEALING (+A)
Step2 · SOFT ANNEALING (+A)​‌​​‌​
SummarySets the delivery condition and machinability. Used before hardening and for repair work after welding.​‌​​‌​
TemperatureEUROPEAN PRACTICE 750-820 °C: BÖHLER 750-800 °C · Dörrenberg 750-790 °C · Stauberstahl 760-780 °C · ABRAMS 750-800 °C · Lucefin 800-810 °C · Marks 800-820 °C. DIVERGING SOURCES: BGH 820-880 °C; US practice is higher – Carpenter 843-871 °C (1550-1600 °F), AZoM and SteelPRO 871 °C (1600 °F). NO AVERAGE HAS BEEN TAKEN.​‌​​‌​
TimeBÖHLER 6-8 hours · Stauberstahl 4-6 hours · ABRAMS and Marks about 4 hours. No single numerical time was confirmed across four independent sources, so no binding time is stated.​‌​​‌​
CoolingCONTROLLED SLOW FURNACE COOLING. BÖHLER 10-20 °C/h down to 600 °C, then air · Lucefin 20-25 °C/h down to 600 °C, then air · Marks and ABRAMS furnace cool to 500 °C, then air · Carpenter 20 °F/h maximum · AZoM and SteelPRO 4.4 °C/h.​‌​​‌​
Resulting hardness229 HBW MAXIMUM. BÖHLER, Dörrenberg, Lucefin, Stauberstahl, BGH, ABRAMS and Virgamet all give the same figure (seven sources). DIVERGING SOURCE: Carpenter gives 241 HB maximum (US practice).​‌​​‌​

3 · STRESS RELIEVING (+SR)
Step​‌​​‌​3 · STRESS RELIEVING (+SR)
Summary​‌​​‌​Carried out after rough machining and BEFORE hardening; it reduces distortion. It does not replace the hardening step.
Temperature​‌​​‌​600-670 °C. BÖHLER 600-670 °C · Dörrenberg 600-650 °C · Stauberstahl 600-650 °C · Saglam Metal 600-650 °C · ABRAMS 600-650 °C · Marks 650 °C · Thermodur 2343 EFS 649 °C (1200 °F). Seven sources sit in the same band.
Time​‌​​‌​BÖHLER 2-6 hours (by tool size) · Stauberstahl 2-3 hours · Marks 2 hours · ABRAMS at least 4 hours · Thermodur 2 hours.
Cooling​‌​​‌​SLOW FURNACE COOLING in a neutral atmosphere (BÖHLER, Dörrenberg, Stauberstahl, Marks, ABRAMS).
Resulting hardness​‌​​‌​This step has no hardness target; the soft annealed hardness is retained.
​‌​​‌​

4 · PREHEATING STAGES (before hardening)
Step4 · PREHEATING STAGES (before hardening)​‌​​‌​
SummaryA 5% Cr hot work steel is NOT taken straight up to the austenitising temperature; staged preheating reduces distortion and the risk of cracking.​‌​​‌​
TemperatureTHE SOURCES GIVE DIFFERENT SCHEMES; NO AVERAGE HAS BEEN TAKEN. ROVALMA gives a two-stage scheme: room temperature to 650 °C (2 h), hold at 650 °C for 2 h, 650 °C to 850 °C (2 h), hold at 850 °C for 2 h. AZoM and SteelPRO give a single stage: 816 °C (1500 °F). Aobo Steel gives 760-815 °C. Shahnaz Bright Steel gives a 310-370 °C preheat for a hardfacing cycle – THAT IS A DIFFERENT OPERATION, not a hardening preheat, and must not be confused with it.​‌​​‌​
TimeROVALMA gives a 2-hour hold at each stage. The other sources give no numerical hold time.​‌​​‌​
CoolingNo cooling; the preheat runs straight on into the austenitising temperature.​‌​​‌​
Resulting hardnessThis step produces no hardness.​‌​​‌​

5 · AUSTENITISING + QUENCH (hardening)
Step​‌​​‌​5 · AUSTENITISING + QUENCH (hardening)
Summary​‌​​‌​This is the step that produces the hardness. Carbon and alloying elements go into solid solution and the rapid cool turns the structure to martensite.
Temperature​‌​​‌​CORE BAND 1000-1030 °C. BÖHLER W300 ISOBLOC and ISODISC 1000-1030 °C (1000-1010 °C for die casting) · Stauberstahl 1010-1030 °C · Stahlwerk Augustfehn 1010-1030 °C · Lucefin 1020 °C · Akrostal 1020 °C · NADCA #207 (for H13) 1030 °C ± 5 °C. SOURCES THAT RAISE THE UPPER LIMIT: ROVALMA and ABRAMS 1000-1040 °C · Dörrenberg and Saglam Metal 1000-1050 °C · BGH 1010-1050 °C · Virgamet 980-1050 °C. DIVERGING LOWER BAND: Aobo Steel 995-1025 °C · AZoM 1010 °C. A study published in the Journal of Materials Processing Technology measures the HIGHEST fracture toughness (KIc) and hardness in H11 at a 1020 °C austenitising temperature. NO AVERAGE HAS BEEN TAKEN.
Time​‌​​‌​BÖHLER 15-30 minutes after temperature equalisation · ROVALMA 30 minutes · AZoM, SteelPRO and Tech Steel 15-40 minutes · Carpenter 20 minutes plus 5 minutes per 25 mm. No single numerical time was confirmed across four independent sources, so no binding time is stated.
Cooling​‌​​‌​AIR · OIL · SALT BATH (500-550 °C) · VACUUM / PRESSURISED GAS. BÖHLER: oil, 500-550 °C salt bath, air, vacuum · Dörrenberg and Saglam Metal: oil, pressurised gas (N2), air, hot bath · BGH: nitrogen at 5 bar minimum, oil, polymer, salt bath · Lucefin: oil, polymer, 450-500 °C salt bath · ABRAMS: air, oil, 500-550 °C hot bath · ROVALMA: oil, 500 °C salt bath, air · Carpenter: air or oil. A WATER QUENCH IS PROHIBITED (Aobo Steel states this explicitly). COOLING RATE REQUIREMENT: NADCA #207 requires a minimum of 28 °C/minute (50 °F/minute) between 1030 °C and 540 °C.
Resulting hardness​‌​​‌​The as-quenched (untempered) hardness lies in the 54-56 HRC band and the sources do not fully agree: Lucefin measures 54 HRC at a 50 °C temper (so the as-quenched value is just above that) · Stahlwerk Augustfehn 54.2 HRC · Aobo Steel about 56 HRC · Shahnaz 54 HRC. BÖHLER gives a 40-55 HRC band for heat treated delivery. NO SINGLE VALUE IS STATED. In this condition the material is brittle and IS NOT USED WITHOUT TEMPERING.
​‌​​‌​

6 · FIRST TEMPER – ABOVE THE SECONDARY HARDNESS PEAK
Step6 · FIRST TEMPER – ABOVE THE SECONDARY HARDNESS PEAK​‌​​‌​
SummaryCarried out IMMEDIATELY after quenching. The temperature is taken from ABOVE the secondary hardness peak, never from below it.​‌​​‌​
TemperatureThe BÖHLER rule: the first temper sits about 30 °C ABOVE MAXIMUM SECONDARY HARDNESS. NADCA #207: first temper at 565 °C minimum for at least 2 hours. Aircraft Materials (aerospace H-11): at a temperature NOT LOWER THAN 538 °C (1000 °F). Aobo Steel: above 510 °C for optimum toughness. As producer bands, Dörrenberg and Saglam Metal give 500-550 °C, Stahlwerk Augustfehn 540-560 °C and Virgamet 450-550 °C.​‌​​‌​
TimeBÖHLER: 1 hour in the furnace for each 20 mm of workpiece thickness, BUT AT LEAST 2 HOURS · ROVALMA: 2.5 minutes per millimetre of thickness, minimum 1 hour · NADCA #207: 1 hour per 25.4 mm, minimum 2 hours · Stauberstahl: 2 hours.​‌​​‌​
CoolingIN AIR TO ROOM TEMPERATURE. During this cooling the retained austenite turns into fresh (untempered) martensite; that is the reason for the second temper.​‌​​‌​
Resulting hardnessSee the tempering table. The hardness after the first temper is above the final hardness reached after the second temper.​‌​​‌​

7 · SECOND TEMPER (MANDATORY) AND THIRD TEMPER (RECOMMENDED)
Step​‌​​‌​7 · SECOND TEMPER (MANDATORY) AND THIRD TEMPER (RECOMMENDED)
Summary​‌​​‌​THE SECOND TEMPER IS NOT OPTIONAL. The fresh martensite formed while cooling from the first temper is tempered only by the second temper.
Temperature​‌​​‌​BÖHLER: the second temper is chosen for the DESIRED WORKING HARDNESS; a third temper may be carried out for stress relief at 30-50 °C (86-122 °F) BELOW the highest tempering temperature. Aircraft Materials keeps all three tempers for aerospace H-11 at or above 538 °C.
Time​‌​​‌​The BÖHLER rule applies to each temper (1 hour per 20 mm, minimum 2 hours). Aircraft Materials gives 2-3 hours for each of the three tempers. Stauberstahl says ‘twice, 2 hours each’. ROVALMA gives 2-3 cycles.
Cooling​‌​​‌​FULL COOL TO ROOM TEMPERATURE IN AIR AFTER EVERY TEMPER. Uddeholm: ‘Tool steels should always be at least double tempered. The second tempering takes care of the newly formed martensite during cooling after the first tempering.’
Resulting hardness​‌​​‌​WORKING HARDNESS: ABRAMS 50-54 HRC · Saglam Metal 46-54 HRC (52-54 HRC maximum after austenitising at 1000-1050 °C and tempering at 500-550 °C) · BÖHLER heat treated delivery 40-55 HRC · Marks: 44-47 HRC for hot work, 48-53 HRC for plastic moulds · Stauberstahl target 53-54 HRC · Stahlwerk Augustfehn about 52 HRC at a 540-560 °C temper.
​‌​​‌​

Tempering table
NoteThe table shows the relationship between tempering temperature and hardness, and EVERY ROW IS GIVEN WITH ITS SOURCE. The Lucefin and Akrostal rows are curves MEASURED on specimens OIL quenched from 1020 °C. HOW TO READ IT: hardness falls to about 52 HRC at 200-300 °C, then RISES AGAIN and PEAKS at about 56 HRC between 450 and 510 °C, after which it drops sharply beyond 550 °C. This table is not an ordering specification; the working hardness is taken from the falling branch to the RIGHT of the peak.​‌​​‌​

SECONDARY HARDNESS PEAK – around 450-510 °C
Step​‌​​‌​SECONDARY HARDNESS PEAK – around 450-510 °C
Mechanism​‌​​‌​The peak has two sources. (a) PRECIPITATION OF FINELY DISPERSED ALLOY CARBIDES: a study of H13 published in Materials (MDPI, 2025) measures Mo2C and VC carbides precipitating in a ‘finely dispersed’ form at a single 520 °C temper, giving a ‘dispersion strengthening effect’, while at 580 °C those carbides coarsen into Cr7C3 and Fe3M3C phases – the coarsening explains the falling branch. (b) TRANSFORMATION OF RETAINED AUSTENITE: Uddeholm states that on cooling after tempering most of the retained austenite transforms to new (untempered) martensite, and that ‘precipitated secondary (newly formed) carbides and newly formed martensite can increase hardness during high temperature tempering’, which is what is called secondary hardening.
What happens​‌​​‌​As the tempering temperature is raised, hardness first falls to about 52 HRC near 200-250 °C, then RISES AGAIN and peaks at about 56 HRC between 450 and 510 °C. Past the peak it drops sharply: 46 HRC at 600 °C and 39 HRC at 650 °C.
As named in the source​‌​​‌​Lucefin (1020 °C oil, measured curve): 52 HRC at 250 °C, 53.5 HRC at 350 °C, 55.5 HRC at 450 °C, 56 HRC at 510 °C – PEAK. Akrostal (1020 °C oil): 53.5 HRC at 350 °C, 54.5 HRC at 400 °C, 55.5 HRC at 450 °C, 56 HRC at 500 °C – PEAK. Stauberstahl: 55 ± 1 HRC at 400 °C, 56 ± 1 HRC at 450 °C, 56 ± 1 HRC at 500 °C – PEAK. Virgamet: 55.9-56.2 HRC at 450 °C, 56.3 HRC at 500 °C – PEAK. Materials (MDPI, 2025) describes 520 °C as ‘a typical secondary hardening temperature for H13 steel’ and measures 590.83 HV after a single 520 °C temper.
Contrary evidence​‌​​‌​The Schmolz + Bickenbach Thermodur 2343 EFS data sheet gives 54 HRC at 400 °C, 52 HRC at 500 °C and 52 HRC at 550 °C; the 450-510 °C peak DOES NOT APPEAR in that table. This divergence is recorded and no peak value was taken from that source. The height of the peak is sensitive to the austenitising temperature, the section size and where the measurement is taken.
Reason​‌​​‌​Two reasons. (1) RETAINED AUSTENITE IS NOT TRANSFORMED: in a part tempered below the peak, part of the retained austenite survives as it is; the part stays brittle and its dimensions move in service. (2) THE TOOL HARDENS BY ITSELF IN SERVICE AND THEN SOFTENS: a die whose surface reaches 500 °C but which was tempered at 400 °C passes through the peak temperature in service – it first hardens, then softens, so hardness and dimensions change in service. THE WORKING HARDNESS IS THEREFORE TAKEN FROM THE FALLING BRANCH TO THE RIGHT OF THE PEAK. Sources that set this as a requirement: BÖHLER (first temper about 30 °C above maximum secondary hardness) · NADCA #207 (first temper at 565 °C minimum for at least 2 hours) · Aircraft Materials (none of the three tempers for aerospace H-11 may go below 538 °C) · Aobo Steel (above 510 °C for optimum toughness).
​‌​​‌​

WHY DOUBLE TEMPERING IS MANDATORY – TRANSFORMATION OF RETAINED AUSTENITE
StepWHY DOUBLE TEMPERING IS MANDATORY – TRANSFORMATION OF RETAINED AUSTENITE​‌​​‌​
ResultA single temper IS NOT ACCEPTABLE for H11. Three tempers are standard practice for aerospace H-11 and for die casting dies. After every temper the part is cooled ALL THE WAY TO ROOM TEMPERATURE; leaving it hot between two tempers defeats the purpose of the second temper.​‌​​‌​
MechanismThe structure after quenching is not entirely martensite; some austenite remains untransformed (retained austenite). During the first temper that retained austenite becomes unstable and, ON COOLING AFTER THE TEMPER, turns into fresh martensite. That fresh martensite IS UNTEMPERED: it is hard, brittle and carries internal stress. The second temper tempers it. A part left with a single temper contains untempered martensite, so it is brittle and dimensionally unstable.​‌​​‌​
As named in the sourceUddeholm (voestalpine), ‘Heat Treatment of Uddeholm Tool Steels’: ‘Tool steels should always be at least double tempered. The second tempering takes care of the newly formed martensite during cooling after the first tempering.’ The same booklet recommends THREE tempers for ‘high speed steel with high carbon content’ and for ‘complex hot work tools, especially in the case of die casting dies’. BÖHLER W300 ISOBLOC and W300 ISODISC: ‘it is recommended to temper at least twice’; the first temper about 30 °C above maximum secondary hardness, the second to the desired working hardness, the third for stress relief. Carpenter Technology (CarTech No. 882 / H11): ‘Double and even triple tempering is suggested to produce optimum mechanical properties, particularly those associated with ductility.’ NADCA #207: ‘A minimum of two tempering cycles are required before finishing operations.’ Lucefin: ‘Two tempers are advised.’ ROVALMA: 2-3 tempering cycles immediately after hardening. Stauberstahl and Grimm: ‘twice, 2 hours each’. Aircraft Materials (aerospace H-11 / DYNAFLEX VAC-ARC): ‘temper three times for 2-3 hours at a temperature not lower than 1000 °F (538 °C) and air cool’. Materials (MDPI, 2025): double tempering ‘promotes the complete transformation of residual retained austenite’ and gives a toughness level unattainable with a single temper, at a cost of a 1.7% drop in hardness.​‌​​‌​
The diagram is schematic; the time axis is NOT to scale. No TTT/CCT curve numerically confirmed across four independent sources was used, so no curve is drawn. THIS ALLOY IS A 5% CHROMIUM HOT WORK TOOL STEEL: it hardens by austenitising, quenching in air, oil or a salt bath, and DOUBLE – preferably TRIPLE – TEMPERING. It does NOT precipitation harden; there is NO AGEING STEP of the H900 / H1025 / H1150 type. The tempering curve has a SECONDARY HARDNESS PEAK; see the tempering table and the secondary hardening box below. The seven steps below were each verified separately. This is a CYCLE DIAGRAM, not a TTT/CCT curve. The time axis is not to scale. H11 DOES NOT PRECIPITATION HARDEN. The terms ‘ageing’, ‘H900’ and ‘solution treatment’ DO NOT APPLY to this alloy. It hardens by austenitising, quenching and multiple tempering. A SINGLE TEMPER IS NOT ACCEPTABLE. Double tempering is the minimum requirement and triple tempering is standard in aerospace and die casting work. The tempering temperature is never taken from BELOW the secondary hardness peak; the working hardness comes from the falling branch to the right of the peak. The figures in the tempering table were measured on small specimens of the order of Ø10 mm. In heavy die blocks the centre cools more slowly and THE SAME tempering temperature gives LOWER hardness. The quench rate requirement (NADCA #207: at least 28 °C/minute between 1030 and 540 °C) is a toughness requirement, not a hardness requirement; slow cooling produces grain boundary carbide precipitation and pearlite and lowers the Charpy value.

The expected ASME table is EMPTY here too, and for the same reason: H11 is not a pressure-equipment material. But H11 does have a real and very important temperature discussion — on the metallurgical side rather than the code side.​‌​​‌​

What Sets H11’s Temperature Limit

The tempering temperature — the absolute rule​‌​​‌​Service temperature must stay BELOW the tempering temperature used. Above it, the part goes on tempering itself in service: hardness falls, dimensions move, and none of it is reversible. On the aerospace route tempering is done at ≥538 °C (1000 °F); on a die it is chosen to suit the working hardness
The published “resistance to softening” figure​‌​​‌​The wording published for the aerospace side is: resists softening up to 1000 °F (538 °C). Carpenter additionally reports high creep and rupture strength between 427 and 649 °C (800–1200 °F). These two are not the same claim: the first is about hardness retention, the second about carrying load for a short to medium term
Above 600 °C — WHERE IT FAILS​‌​​‌​Above 600 °C, H11 softens fast. A published tempering table, for specimens oil quenched from 1020 °C, gives 46 HRC at 550 °C and 30 HRC at 650 °C — sixteen HRC points in a hundred degrees. H11 is NOT a high-temperature alloy, and an application carrying continuous load above 600 °C needs a nickel-base alloy or something in the Hastelloy X class
Hot yield strength​‌​​‌​For 1.2343 tempered to 48 HRC the producer reports Rm 1620 MPa and Rp 1380 MPa at room temperature, and a hot yield strength of 600 MPa at 600 °C. So it loses well over half its strength at 600 °C — yet is still close to the room-temperature strength of many steels. That sums up what H11 is: an exceptional hot steel, but still a STEEL
The fall of modulus with temperature​‌​​‌​210,000 MPa at 20 °C → 180,000 MPa at 400 °C → 140,000 MPa at 600 °C. Using the room-temperature modulus in a hot die stiffness calculation is an error of up to 33 %
The code side​‌​​‌​There is no ASME acceptance and none should be sought. H11’s acceptance regime is NADCA in tooling and AMS plus OEM in aerospace

Product Forms With NO Standard — the Commercially Most Valuable Section​‌​​‌​

This is the section your sales engineers should memorise. H11’s coverage is limited to tool-steel product forms on the ASTM A681 side, and to bar, forgings and forging stock only on the AMS side.

Specification Gaps for T20811

​‌​​‌​

Plate · sheet · stripThere is NO plate/sheet specification for H11. As a flat tooling product it is sold as plate cut from a block, which is not a rolled-plate specification. Size, tolerance and inspection are by agreement​‌​​‌​
Seamless pipe / tubeThere is NO tubular product specification for H11. Where a bore is needed it is machined or gun-drilled from bar or block. Extrusion containers, mandrels and similar hollow parts are made that way. AMS 6487 does not cover tubing either — only bar, forgings and forging stock​‌​​‌​
WireOne producer lists H11 in wire form, but no wire product specification was found. Annealed wire and above all matching wire drawn for weld filler do exist commercially, but are sold to company specification​‌​​‌​
CastingsThere is NO standardised cast equivalent of H11. A hot-work die is machined from a forged block, not cast — and there is a technical reason: forging is what gives the directionality and internal soundness that set die life. A cast hot-work die does not substitute for a forged one in heat checking or internal soundness​‌​​‌​
Bolts · nuts · fastenersAn interesting exception: H11 genuinely is used as a high-strength aerospace fastener material — but not under the name H11; under a fastener specification calling out AMS 6487 material. When an “H11 bolt” is requested, the real question is which fastener specification applies​‌​​‌​
Covered electrodes / welding wireThere is NO AWS classification in H11 chemistry. Die repair welding is done with matching wire drawn to the base metal or with proprietary branded fillers​‌​​‌​
Flanges · fittings · valvesNone, and there should be none. H11 is not a pressure-equipment material​‌​​‌​
Powder metallurgy / additive manufacturingH11/1.2343 powder is commercially available and laser metal deposition is used in die repair. No published AM product specification was found in this study; additively manufactured H11 has different residual stress, porosity and tempering behaviour from the wrought equivalent​‌​​‌​

Chemical Composition

Three different composition bands circulate under the name H11, and all three are called “H11”. The differences look small, but the width of the carbon band is hardness scatter in disguise — and the aerospace band has been narrowed deliberately.​‌​​‌​

Chemical Composition · ASTM A681 H11 — weight %

Carbon (C)​‌​​‌​0.33 – 0.43 — [D] one secondary source gives the band as 0.35–0.45. The majority and ASTM position is 0.33–0.43; confirm from the specification before ordering
Manganese (Mn)​‌​​‌​0.20 – 0.50 — [D] one source gives 0.20–0.60
Silicon (Si)​‌​​‌​0.80 – 1.20 — [D] one source gives 0.80–1.25. That high silicon is not accidental: it improves resistance to wetting and soldering by molten aluminium, and resistance to scaling
Chromium (Cr)​‌​​‌​4.75 – 5.50
Molybdenum (Mo)​‌​​‌​1.10 – 1.60
Vanadium (V)​‌​​‌​0.30 – 0.60 — the ONLY element separating H11 from H13 (0.80–1.20)
Phosphorus (P) · Sulphur (S)​‌​​‌​typically ≤0.030 · ≤0.030 (standard quality). In premium/NADCA classes sulphur is taken down to about 0.001 %
Iron (Fe)​‌​​‌​Balance
Chemical Composition · EN ISO 4957 · 1.2343 X37CrMoV5-1 — weight %

​‌​​‌​

Carbon (C)0.33 – 0.41 — NARROWER than ASTM’s 0.33–0.43​‌​​‌​
Silicon (Si)0.80 – 1.20​‌​​‌​
Manganese (Mn)0.25 – 0.50​‌​​‌​
Chromium (Cr)4.80 – 5.50 — a higher lower limit than ASTM’s (ASTM: 4.75)​‌​​‌​
Molybdenum (Mo)1.10 – 1.50 — a lower upper limit than ASTM’s (ASTM: 1.60)​‌​​‌​
Vanadium (V)0.30 – 0.50 — a lower upper limit than ASTM’s (ASTM: 0.60)​‌​​‌​
Phosphorus (P)≤0.030​‌​​‌​
Sulphur (S)≤0.020 — tighter than ASTM’s typical ≤0.030​‌​​‌​
Conclusion1.2343 sits INSIDE ASTM A681 H11 but is not IDENTICAL to it. Every 1.2343 is an H11; not every H11 is a 1.2343. Material bought to the European specification meets the American one; the reverse is not always true​‌​​‌​
Chemical Composition · AMS 6487 (premium aircraft quality, VAR) — weight %

Carbon (C)​‌​​‌​0.38 – 0.43 — narrowed to the UPPER HALF ONLY of ASTM’s 0.33–0.43 band. The reason is plain: structural use targets strength above 260 ksi, and that cannot be hit with carbon at the bottom of the band. It also narrows the post-heat-treatment hardness scatter
Chromium · Molybdenum · Vanadium​‌​​‌​The nominal in the specification title: 5.0 Cr – 1.3 Mo – 0.50 V
Melt route​‌​​‌​Consumable Electrode Vacuum Re-Melted — VAR is mandatory. This condition governs more than the chemistry does
The sentence worth publishing​‌​​‌​AMS 6487 is not “a better H11”; it is a NARROWER and CLEANER H11. For a die shop that difference is usually money wasted. For a landing-gear manufacturer it is not negotiable
Producer Nominals — All of Them Sold as “H11”

​‌​​‌​

Carpenter H11C 0.40 · Cr 5.00 · Mo 1.35 · V 0.45 · Si ≤0.90 · Mn ≤0.35​‌​​‌​
Böhler W300 (1.2343)C 0.38 · Si 1.10 · Mn 0.40 · Cr 5.00 · Mo 1.20 · V 0.40​‌​​‌​
Uddeholm Vidar 1 ESRC 0.38 · Si 1.0 · Mn 0.4 · Cr 5.0 · Mo 1.3 · V 0.4​‌​​‌​
Uddeholm Vidar SuperiorC 0.36 · Si 0.3 · Mn 0.3 · Cr 5.0 · Mo 1.3 · V 0.5. Silicon at 0.3 instead of 1.0 — this is a different steel from classic 1.2343, and the producer attributes its toughness gain to exactly that​‌​​‌​
Aerospace VAR qualityC 0.40 · Mn 0.30 · Si 0.90 · Cr 5.00 · Mo 1.30 · V 0.50​‌​​‌​
What to read from thisFive nominals, five different steels. Carbon ranges between 0.36 and 0.40, silicon between 0.3 and 1.1, vanadium between 0.40 and 0.50. In a die-life argument, the sentence “we used the same material” means nothing without a producer name​‌​​‌​

Heat Treatment — All of H11 Is Here

Buying H11 is the easy part. This steel’s entire character — hardness, toughness, dimensional stability and heat-checking resistance — is decided in the chain of preheat, austenitize, quench rate and DOUBLE (or even triple) tempering. And the most frequently skipped link in that chain is the number of tempers.​‌​​‌​

Heat Treatment Temperatures · H11 / 1.2343

Hot working (forging)​‌​​‌​Forged at about 1121 °C; forging is not continued below 899 °C. Annealing after forging is mandatory
Soft annealing — THE SOURCES DIVERGE [D]​‌​​‌​Böhler: 750–800 °C, 6–8 hours, furnace cool at 10–20 °C/h to 600 °C, then air. Uddeholm: 850 °C, furnace cool at 10 °C/h to 650 °C, then air. One European publisher: 800–810 °C, 20–25 °C/h to 600 °C. US sources: 871 °C, furnace cool at 4.4 °C/h. Do not average them. The outcome criterion is common to all: annealed hardness ≤229 HB (in premium/NADCA classes the ceiling is around 235 HBW)
Stress relieving — TWO DIFFERENT OPERATIONS, CONSTANTLY CONFLATED [D]​‌​​‌​(a) BEFORE hardening, after rough machining: one source gives 350 °C, another 600–670 °C for 2–6 hours, another 650 °C for 2 hours. (b) AFTER hardening, after grinding or EDM: 28–42 °C BELOW the final tempering temperature. These are not the same operation, and confusing them softens a hardened part. Always state which stage you are at
Preheating (before hardening)​‌​​‌​It must be stepped. Published practice: one or two steps between 600 and 850 °C; one producer recommends two steps at 600–650 °C and 820–900 °C; a US source gives a single step at 816 °C. The purpose is to avoid thermal stress and cracking in a steel with low thermal conductivity (~25 W/m·K)
Austenitizing (hardening)​‌​​‌​1000 – 1030 °C (Böhler) · 990 – 1010 °C (Uddeholm Vidar 1, typically 990–1000) · 980 – 1000 °C (Vidar Superior) · 1000 – 1040 °C into oil (one European publisher) · 982 – 1038 °C and 1010 °C (US sources). Soak 15–45 minutes. The common ground is around 1000 °C. At the high end, hardness and hot strength rise, grain coarsens and TOUGHNESS FALLS — that trade must be made consciously in H11
Decarburization​‌​​‌​A protective atmosphere or vacuum is MANDATORY at 1000 °C. A decarburized surface leaves a soft layer, open to heat checking, on the die face — and that layer is precisely where thermal fatigue begins
Quenching​‌​​‌​H11 is AIR HARDENING — and that is the fundamental reason it is a die steel: large blocks harden without distorting. Practicable routes: high-speed gas (vacuum furnace), oil, salt bath or air. Martempering baths: 500–550 °C or 180–220 °C. But air hardening does not mean slow cooling is permitted
Quench RATE — the most overlooked variable​‌​​‌​If cooling is too slow, carbides precipitate on the grain boundaries and TOUGHNESS COLLAPSES. A hardness test will not show it — the part passes the hardness check and breaks in service. That is exactly why the die-casting world imposes a minimum cooling rate requirement. Practical rule: the fastest cooling compatible with acceptable distortion
Moving to tempering​‌​​‌​The part goes to tempering IMMEDIATELY once it reaches 50–70 °C. As-quenched H11 left standing at room temperature will crack on its own. This is the most common and most easily prevented failure in H11

Double — or triple — tempering: why it is not negotiable​‌​​‌​

H11 carries appreciable RETAINED AUSTENITE after quenching. 5 % chromium, 1.3 % molybdenum and 0.4 % carbon push Ms/Mf down far enough that part of the structure is still austenite when the quench ends.
The first temper does two things: it tempers the martensite already present and it destabilises the retained austenite. On cooling from that temper, the austenite transforms to fresh, untempered martensite. So at the end of the first temper, your part contains brittle, hard, completely untempered martensite.
The second temper is what tempers that fresh martensite. This is why “temper twice” is not advice but a metallurgical necessity, and why the part must be cooled to room temperature between the two cycles — otherwise the transformation does not complete.
When is a third temper needed? It is standard in aerospace structural use: the published route is austenitize at 1010 °C for 15–45 minutes, air cool, then temper THREE times for 2–3 hours at a temperature not lower than 538 °C (1000 °F), air cooling after each. In heavy sections, at high working hardness and on critical parts, the third cycle is a margin against any remaining retained austenite.
Each temper cycle is held for at least 2 hours, extended with section thickness — and it is the PART reaching temperature that counts, not the furnace.

The secondary hardening peak — and where the sources diverge​‌​​‌​

H11 does not soften monotonically as it is tempered. At low temperature the martensite tempers and hardness falls a little; then fine molybdenum and vanadium carbides begin to precipitate and hardness RISES AGAIN. This is secondary hardening, and it is why H11 is a hot-work steel at all.
The published data diverge on where the peak sits [D]:
One European publisher’s table (oil from 1020 °C, ø20 mm specimen): 200 °C → 52 HRC (1880 MPa), 300 °C → 52.5 HRC (1915 MPa), 400 °C → 54.5 HRC (2040 MPa), 550 °C → 46 HRC (1520 MPa), 650 °C → 30 HRC (950 MPa) — on that table the peak is around 400 °C.
A producer’s tempering graph, by contrast, shows roughly 53 HRC at 200 °C, 51 at 400 °C, 47 at 600 °C and 45 at 650 °C — that is a far flatter curve and markedly higher hardness at 600 °C.
Do not ignore the discrepancy; its explanation is the austenitizing temperature. A higher austenitizing temperature dissolves more chromium, molybdenum and vanadium into the matrix, and the secondary hardening peak both rises and shifts to a higher tempering temperature. There is therefore no such thing as “the tempering curve of H11”. Whenever you publish one, state the austenitizing temperature, the specimen diameter and the number of cycles — without them the table is unusable.

Choosing the Tempering Band · Practical Guide

​‌​​‌​

The band to AVOID for toughness425 – 550 °C. One producer explicitly marks this range as one to be avoided for toughness. That it coincides with the secondary hardening region is no accident: the band that gives the highest hardness also gives the lowest toughness​‌​​‌​
Aluminium die casting diesWorking hardness is typically held around 46 – 50 HRC — single-sourced; it varies with die size and cast alloy​‌​​‌​
Copper alloy die casting diesLower: 41 – 46 HRC — single-sourced. A higher casting temperature means more severe thermal shock, and hardness is given up in favour of toughness​‌​​‌​
Aerospace structural (AMS 6487)Temper at ≥538 °C (1000 °F), three times, 2–3 hours. The target is not maximum hardness but around 260 ksi strength with acceptable toughness​‌​​‌​
The rule not to breakService temperature must stay below the chosen tempering temperature. That single sentence sums up the whole temperature discussion for H11​‌​​‌​
Dimensional Change and Distortion

Machining allowance​‌​​‌​An allowance of 0.2 % of the dimension in length, width and thickness is recommended — to absorb the change produced by transformation and thermal stresses
The advantage of air hardening​‌​​‌​This is the single most important reason H11 is a die steel. In an oil- or water-quenched steel a large block inevitably distorts and cracks; because H11 hardens in air, large sections harden with acceptable distortion
The dimensional effect of retained austenite​‌​​‌​The austenite → martensite transformation is a VOLUME INCREASE. In an under-tempered part that transformation happens in service and the die grows on its own. Double/triple tempering is also a dimensional stability measure
When to finish grind​‌​​‌​AFTER every tempering cycle is complete. If a cycle remains, the ground dimension will move in it
Balanced machining​‌​​‌​Removing metal asymmetrically from a large block produces asymmetric distortion in heat treatment. Stress relief after rough machining is not negotiable on a precision die

Premium Aircraft Quality H11 (AMS 6487) — H11’s Little-Known Second Life​‌​​‌​

Filing H11 away as a tool steel misses half of it. The same chemistry, vacuum melted and with the carbon band narrowed, is used in aerospace and defence as an ultra-high-strength structural steel — on the same shelf as 4340, 300M and maraging 250.

Why H11 Is Used as a Structural Steel

​‌​​‌​

Strength levelProducer wording: strength in excess of 260,000 psi (1793 MPa). Published typical longitudinal values: Rm 1793 MPa (260 ksi) · Rp0.2 1482 MPa (215 ksi) · Elongation 8 % · Reduction of area 30 %. One source reports that ductility and toughness are retained even at about 275 ksi (1896 MPa)​‌​​‌​
Resistance to softeningIt resists softening up to 538 °C (1000 °F). That is what 4340 and 300M cannot do: those steels are tempered far lower and lose their strength in a structure that heats up. In a structural part seeing aerodynamic heating, engine proximity or brake heat, H11 is a genuine advantage​‌​​‌​
Creep and rupture strengthCarpenter: high creep and rupture strength between 427 and 649 °C (800–1200 °F). An unusual claim for a structural steel, and it comes directly from the secondary hardening carbides​‌​​‌​
Air hardening = low distortionIn a heavy landing-gear forging, hardening in air removes the distortion and cracking risk of an oil quench. On large, complex, thick-section structural forgings that alone can justify the selection​‌​​‌​
ApplicationsLanding gear components, aircraft and missile structural parts, high-strength aerospace fasteners, rocket motor case components. It has also been adapted to COLD work applications where toughness matters more than wear resistance​‌​​‌​
ApprovalsOne American mill produces H11 by an AOD + VAR route and cites AMS 6485 / 6487 / 6488 and EMS-642 (Allied Signal / Garrett) plus Pratt & Whitney and Bombardier approvals. (Remember that AMS 6485 and 6488 have been cancelled — that list shows historical scope)​‌​​‌​
Why doesn’t everyone use it?Three reasons. (1) Price: VAR melting and three tempering cycles are expensive. (2) Ductility: 8 % elongation and 30 % reduction of area are low against quenched and tempered 4340 — a constraint in damage-tolerant design. (3) Hydrogen sensitivity: like every steel in the 1793 MPa class, H11 is susceptible to hydrogen embrittlement and a post-plating bake is mandatory​‌​​‌​

Mechanical Properties

​‌​​‌​

STRENGTH VALUES
Yield (MPa)Tensile (MPa)Soft annealed (+A) delivery condition770Double tempered · 52 HRC (2 h at 550 °C)1790Tempered · 52 HRC (ESR quality, 300 K)18501570Tempered · 48 HRC (2 h at 600 °C)1570Tempered · about 46 HRC (ESU/ESR quality)15001270Tempered · 31 HRC (2 h at 700 °C)1200AEROSPACE H-11 (vacuum remelted, longitudinal specimen)17931482

ConditionHardnessYield MPaTensile MPaElongation
Soft annealed (+A) delivery condition​‌​​‌​229 HBW maximum (BÖHLER, Dörrenberg, Lucefin, Stauberstahl, BGH, ABRAMS, Virgamet). DIVERGING: Carpenter 241 HB maximum—​‌​​‌​about 770 (ABRAMS, single source)—​‌​​‌​
As quenched, untempered (1020 °C oil)54-56 HRC (Lucefin 54 · Stahlwerk Augustfehn 54.2 · Shahnaz 54 · Aobo Steel about 56)​‌​​‌​——​‌​​‌​—
Double tempered · 52 HRC (2 h at 550 °C)​‌​​‌​52 HRC—​‌​​‌​1790—​‌​​‌​
Tempered · 52 HRC (ESR quality, 300 K)52 HRC​‌​​‌​15701850​‌​​‌​10.7%
Tempered · 48 HRC (2 h at 600 °C)​‌​​‌​48 HRC—​‌​​‌​1570—​‌​​‌​
Tempered · about 46 HRC (ESU/ESR quality)about 46 HRC​‌​​‌​about 1270about 1500​‌​​‌​13%
Tempered · 44 HRC (impact)​‌​​‌​44 HRC—​‌​​‌​——​‌​​‌​
Tempered · 31 HRC (2 h at 700 °C)31 HRC​‌​​‌​—1200​‌​​‌​—
AEROSPACE H-11 (vacuum remelted, longitudinal specimen)​‌​​‌​—1482​‌​​‌​17938%​‌​​‌​
NADCA #207 acceptance criterion (die casting dies)—​‌​​‌​——​‌​​‌​—
Physical constants​‌​​‌​——​‌​​‌​——​‌​​‌​
THERE ARE NO SPECIFICATION MINIMA IN THIS TABLE. ASTM A681 and EN ISO 4957 do not give tensile or yield minima for tool steels; both work through chemistry and an annealed hardness ceiling. The AMS 6487 and 6437 texts are paid documents and their mechanical minima could not be verified across four independent sources (see the omissions list). Every figure in the table is a PRODUCER TYPICAL VALUE and is given with its source. Hardness and strength are paired WITHIN A SINGLE SOURCE; hardness and strength figures from different sources have NOT been placed side by side. Fracture toughness falls as hardness rises. Marks gives KIc of about 75 MPa·m^0.5 at 46 HRC; Thermodur gives a notched Charpy of 13.6-16.3 J at 44 HRC. Hardness alone is not a sufficient acceptance criterion when buying a die, which is why NADCA #207 imposes a Charpy requirement. The aerospace H-11 row CANNOT be compared with the tool steel rows: it belongs to vacuum remelted material and to the AMS heat treatment.

Publishing a single table of mechanical properties for H11 is wrong, because the same steel can sit anywhere between 30 HRC and 55 HRC depending on the tempering temperature chosen. Every row below states which heat-treated condition it belongs to.​‌​​‌​

Hardness and Strength · H11 / 1.2343

Annealed (as supplied)​‌​​‌​≤229 HB (European publisher). In premium/NADCA classes the ceiling is given as around 235 HBW
As quenched, untempered​‌​​‌​56 HRC after air cooling from 1010 °C. Varies between 52.5 and 57 HRC depending on the austenitizing temperature
Post-tempering band​‌​​‌​54 → 38 HRC across tempering at 538 – 649 °C (1000–1200 °F). That is H11’s entire working range
Tempering table (oil from 1020 °C, ø20)​‌​​‌​200 °C → 52 HRC / 1880 MPa · 300 °C → 52.5 HRC / 1915 MPa · 400 °C → 54.5 HRC / 2040 MPa · 550 °C → 46 HRC / 1520 MPa · 650 °C → 30 HRC / 950 MPa. [Single-sourced; a producer’s graph shows a flatter curve — see the secondary hardening section]
Tensile properties at 48 HRC​‌​​‌​Rm 1620 MPa · Rp 1380 MPa (producer data)
Aerospace structural condition (VAR, longitudinal)​‌​​‌​Rm 1793 MPa (260 ksi) · Rp0.2 1482 MPa (215 ksi) · Elongation 8 % · Reduction of area 30 %
Hot yield strength at 600 °C​‌​​‌​600 MPa (material tempered to 48 HRC, producer data)
Modulus of elasticity​‌​​‌​20 °C: 210,000 MPa → 400 °C: 180,000 MPa → 600 °C: 140,000 MPa. [D] Another producer gives 215 GPa at room temperature and two US sources give 207 GPa. The spread is small; use the 207–215 GPa band]
Toughness — the Sources Diverge Badly [D]

​‌​​‌​

Classic H11 (US sources)Charpy V-notch 13.6 – 33.9 J, depending on tempering temperature. 33.9 J (25 ft-lb) at a 370 °C temper​‌​​‌​
Modified H11 (Vidar Superior type)Charpy V at room temperature ≈ 80 – 100 J. The producer describes this openly as “significant improvements in impact toughness compared to material of the 1.2343 type” and achieves it by cutting silicon from 1.0 % to 0.3 %​‌​​‌​
What that gap meansThree to seven times. These are two different products inside one ASTM grade. If a die is breaking from insufficient toughness, moving to a MODIFIED H11 may buy more than moving from H13 to classic H11 does​‌​​‌​
How toughness relates to hardnessIn any one steel, toughness falls as hardness rises. One producer reports that its improved toughness allows a tool to run at 2 HRC higher working hardness without loss of toughness, and that this limits the formation of thermal fatigue cracks — the clearest published statement of the link between toughness and heat-checking resistance​‌​​‌​
When publishingDo not publish a bare Charpy figure. State the scale (V-notch), the hardness, the tempering temperature, the specimen orientation (longitudinal/transverse) and the quality class. Without those, a toughness number is not information but noise​‌​​‌​

Physical Properties

Two numbers among H11’s physical properties are commercially decisive: its low thermal conductivity (about 25 W/m·K — less than half that of plain carbon steel) and its relatively high thermal expansion. Together they explain why heat checking is the number one failure mode of a hot-work die.​‌​​‌​

Physical Properties · H11 / 1.2343

Density​‌​​‌​7.8 g/cm³ at 20 °C. With temperature: 7.70 at 400 °C · 7.60 g/cm³ at 600 °C. US sources give 7.81 g/cm³ — effectively the same
Modulus of elasticity​‌​​‌​210 GPa (20 °C) → 180 GPa (400 °C) → 140 GPa (600 °C). [D] One producer gives 215 GPa at 20 °C, two US sources give 207 GPa
Thermal conductivity​‌​​‌​≈25 W/m·K (20 °C) → 29 W/m·K (400 °C) → 30 W/m·K (600 °C). [D] IMPORTANT CONFLICT: one US secondary source gives 42.2 W/m·K at 100 °C. That value is inconsistent with the 24.9–25 W/m·K published by two independent European producers and appears to be an outlier. Use the 25 W/m·K band
Mean thermal expansion​‌​​‌​11.5 × 10⁻⁶ /K (20–100 °C) → 12.6 × 10⁻⁶ (to 400 °C) → 13.2 × 10⁻⁶ (to 600–700 °C). One US source gives 11.9 × 10⁻⁶ for 20–100 °C — inside the band
Specific heat​‌​​‌​≈460 J/kg·K (0.46 kJ/kg·K at 20 °C)
Electrical resistivity​‌​​‌​≈0.52 Ω·mm²/m (52 µΩ·cm)
Melting point​‌​​‌​≈1427 °C (2600 °F) — single-sourced; it is given as a single value rather than a range, so no liquidus/solidus distinction is made
Magnetic behaviour​‌​​‌​Ferromagnetic. Magnetic particle inspection is possible and is standard on the aerospace side
Why those two numbers explain heat checking​‌​​‌​Low thermal conductivity means the die face heats and cools very fast each cycle while the body stays cold — that is, a large temperature difference between face and body. High thermal expansion means that temperature difference becomes a large difference in expansion. The result is a compression–tension stress cycle repeated at the surface on every shot. That is heat checking, and it is not a material defect but an inevitability of physics

Thermal Fatigue (Heat Checking) Resistance​‌​​‌​

The number one cause of death of a hot-work die is not wear but heat checking. A fine crack network appears on the surface, invisible at first; it deepens a little each cycle; eventually it prints onto the casting surface and the die is scrapped.

Heat Checking · Mechanism and Where H11 Sits

​‌​​‌​

The mechanismOn each cycle the die face heats rapidly; it wants to expand but is restrained by the cold body → compressive stress and plastic flow at the surface. Then the face cools rapidly; it wants to contract but has already deformed plastically → TENSILE residual stress at the surface. One tension–compression cycle per shot; low-cycle thermal fatigue over tens of thousands of shots​‌​​‌​
Where H11’s advantage comes fromLow vanadium → low carbide volume fraction → fewer crack initiators and higher fracture toughness. The crack both starts later and runs slower. Classic tool-steel practice therefore prefers H11 on water-cooled dies and under severe thermal shock — one US source states explicitly for H11 that it “permits water cooling in service”​‌​​‌​
The counter-view — stated honestlySome current commercial sources argue that H13’s higher hot hardness makes it more resistant to plastic flow at the surface and therefore superior in thermal fatigue. No single peer-reviewed dataset measuring the two grades on the same rig was found in this study. Publish both claims; do not pick one and hide the other​‌​​‌​
The toughness ↔ heat checking linkThere is a numerical piece of evidence: one producer reports that improved toughness lets the tool be run at 2 HRC higher working hardness without loss of toughness, and that this limits the formation of thermal fatigue cracks. In other words, the toughness gain is cashed in directly as the ability to run harder and check less​‌​​‌​
What to do BEFORE changing material1. Die preheat. Shooting hot metal into a cold die produces the most severe thermal shock of the whole campaign in the first shots. 2. Cooling channel design. A channel too close to the face widens the gradient. 3. Surface quality. EDM white layer, grinding marks and sharp corners are crack initiators. 4. Decarburization control. A soft surface layer accelerates heat checking. Changing grade before fixing these is wasted money​‌​​‌​
Surface treatmentsNitriding raises wear and soldering resistance but creates a hard, brittle surface layer; its effect on heat checking is contested and application-dependent. Do not publish a general claim that nitriding improves heat-checking resistance​‌​​‌​

Welding — Repair Welding Above All

H11 is weldable, but welding here is not a manufacturing method — it is a REPAIR method. Filling a worn area of a hardened die, restoring a broken corner, recovering a pocket that has gone oversize. And a repair weld done wrong finishes the die completely.​‌​​‌​

Repair Welding Procedure · H11 / H13 hot-work steels

1. Preparation​‌​​‌​The crack is ground out COMPLETELY. A crack left half removed simply keeps running beneath the weld. The joint is opened to take at least two passes. The surface is cleaned of oil, of aluminium left from casting, and of oxide
2. Preheat — MANDATORY​‌​​‌​327 – 371 °C (620–700 °F) per one US source. One European producer gives a minimum of 325 °C — the two corroborate each other. It must be uniform across the whole part, by torch, furnace or heating blanket; local preheat creates fresh stress
3. Interpass temperature​‌​​‌​Maximum 477 °C (890 °F). Going above that ceiling puts the part through an unintended tempering cycle
4. Filler metal​‌​​‌​In critical areas: a consumable matching the base metal in chemistry and hardness. In non-critical areas: a lower-strength, more ductile nickel-bearing stainless wire may be used — but that area can never be brought back to base metal hardness. TIG wire must be cleaned with light emery before welding
5. Consumable storage​‌​​‌​Opened packs of covered electrodes must be kept in a drying cabinet at 49–149 °C (120–300 °F). Hydrogen is the primary cause of delayed cracking in a hardenable steel
6. Post-weld cooling​‌​​‌​Very slow: 19–28 °C per hour (35–50 °F/h). Rapid cooling leaves untempered martensite in the weld metal and the HAZ
7. Post-weld tempering — THE CRITICAL RULE​‌​​‌​The part is heated to 28–42 °C (50–75 °F) BELOW the previous tempering temperature, held 2 hours, cooled slowly to 427 °C (800 °F), then air cooled. The previous tempering temperature is NEVER exceeded — the moment it is, the whole die softens
What to avoid​‌​​‌​Welding without preheat (immediate cracking) · skipping the post-weld temper (delayed cracking, days later) · exceeding the previous tempering temperature (the whole die softens) · excessive heat input per pass (wide HAZ, large distortion)

Machining and EDM​‌​​‌​

H11 machines well in the annealed condition — published machinability is 75–80 % of 1 % carbon steel. In the hardened condition (46–52 HRC) the work moves to hard turning/milling, grinding and EDM. And EDM is the finishing method that does the most damage in H11.

Machining · Starting Parameters

​‌​​‌​

Condition to machine inAnnealed (≤229 HB). Roughing always before heat treatment; stress relief after roughing​‌​​‌​
Machinability75–80 % of 1 % C steel. Its lower vanadium makes it a little kinder than H13, though the difference is small in practice​‌​​‌​
Turning (carbide, annealed)Roughing: 200–250 m/min · Finishing: 250–300 m/min (producer data)​‌​​‌​
Drilling (HSS)16–18 m/min (producer data)​‌​​‌​
Hard machining (46–52 HRC)CBN or coated ceramic/carbide, negative geometry, light depth of cut, rigid clamping. No published numerical hard-machining parameters were found in this study​‌​​‌​
Polishability“Good” in the as-supplied condition (producer). A low-sulphur, homogeneous quality is excellent for photo-etching and surface texturing — in a plastic injection mould that is itself a reason to select the material​‌​​‌​
GrindingAfter every tempering cycle is complete. Over-aggressive grinding leaves tensile residual stress and grinding burn at the surface — which accelerates heat checking​‌​​‌​
EDM and the White Layer (Recast Layer) — the Step Not to Skip

What forms​‌​​‌​EDM cuts by locally melting and re-solidifying the material. What is left at the surface is re-melted metal that has picked up carbon from the dielectric, quenched, and UNTEMPERED martensite — the white layer / recast layer of the literature
Why it is dangerous​‌​​‌​It is very hard, very brittle and under TENSILE residual stress. Beneath it lies a second, over-tempered and softened layer. That pair is a perfect starting point for heat checking — and once the die goes into service the first cracks appear precisely on the EDM surfaces
The correct route — two steps, both mandatory​‌​​‌​(1) Remove the white layer MECHANICALLY — grinding, stoning, blasting, or a series of light finishing EDM passes followed by mechanical cleaning. (2) RE-TEMPER the part — just below the final tempering temperature. The producer’s wording is unambiguous: after EDM, the recast layer must be removed AND the part must be re-tempered
The common mistake​‌​​‌​Doing only one of the two. Removing the white layer but skipping the re-temper leaves the heat-affected zone beneath it untempered. Re-tempering but leaving the white layer keeps the brittle layer in place
Re-tempering temperature​‌​​‌​It must stay below the final tempering temperature — otherwise the whole die softens. This is the same rule as in repair welding

Corrosion and WHERE IT FAILS​‌​​‌​

COMPARISON
CRITERION: CHEMICAL BANDS READ FROM THE SAME STANDARD TEXT. The band in each column is taken from THE STANDARD THAT COLUMN BELONGS TO (ASTM A681 for H11 and H13, EN ISO 4957 for 1.2344), so the vanadium difference is read under one specification logic. HARDNESS AND STRENGTH FIGURES FROM DIFFERENT SOURCES HAVE NOT BEEN PLACED SIDE BY SIDE; the toughness and wear rows are given in the rating language of one producer (voestalpine BÖHLER) across two pages of the same product family (W300 = 1.2343/H11, W302 = 1.2344/H13). THE MAIN FINDING OF THE TABLE IS THIS: ‘H13’ and ‘1.2344’ are two names for THE SAME STEEL under two different standards, but THEIR BANDS ARE NOT IDENTICAL; H11 and H13, by contrast, ARE GENUINELY TWO DIFFERENT GRADES, and the element that makes the difference is VANADIUM.
​‌​​‌​

GradeUNSW.-Nr.CarbonChromiumMolybdenumVanadiumSiliconSecondary hardeningToughnessTypical use
AISI H11 (ASTM A681)T20811​‌​​‌​EN counterpart 1.2343 / X37CrMoV5-1 – CLOSE EQUIVALENT, THE BANDS ARE NOT IDENTICAL (EN band C 0.33-0.41%, V 0.30-0.50%; ASTM band C 0.33-0.43%, V 0.30-0.60%)0.33-0.43% (AZoM/ASM, SteelPRO, Shahnaz, Aobo Steel). DIVERGING SOURCES: Otai 0.35-0.45% · Virat Steels 0.30-0.40% – NO AVERAGE HAS BEEN TAKEN​‌​​‌​4.75-5.50%1.10-1.60%​‌​​‌​0.30-0.60%0.80-1.20% (AZoM, Shahnaz) · 0.80-1.25% (Aobo Steel, Otai)​‌​​‌​Secondary hardness peak of about 56 HRC at 450-510 °C (Lucefin, Akrostal, Stauberstahl, Virgamet). Working hardness 40-55 HRC.The BÖHLER W300 (1.2343) page states ‘very high hot toughness’, ‘very good resistance against heat-checkings’ and ‘good’ hot hardness.​‌​​‌​Chosen where TOUGHNESS and THERMAL SHOCK resistance, not wear, govern. In aerospace it is used as a high strength structural material under AMS 6487 (CEVM/VAR).
AISI H13 (ASTM A681)​‌​​‌​T20813EN counterpart 1.2344 / X40CrMoV5-1 – CLOSE EQUIVALENT, THE BANDS ARE NOT IDENTICAL (see the next row)​‌​​‌​0.32-0.45% (AZoM/ASM and Otai agree)4.75-5.50%​‌​​‌​1.10-1.75%0.80-1.20%​‌​​‌​0.80-1.20% (AZoM) · 0.80-1.25% (Otai)It belongs to the same 5% Cr family; its hardening band is higher than H11’s: BÖHLER gives 1020-1080 °C for W302 (1020-1030 °C for die casting) against 1000-1030 °C for H11.​‌​​‌​The BÖHLER W302 (1.2344) page states ‘very high hot toughness’ AND ‘VERY HIGH HOT HARDNESS’ with ‘high’ wear resistance. On the H11 page hot hardness is rated only ‘good’.Tech Steel states the difference as follows: H11 contains ‘less vanadium than the commonly used H13’, which gives ‘higher toughness, with some reduction in wear resistance and temper resistance’. SteelPRO gives the same difference as ‘H11 provides higher impact resistance than H13 but lower wear resistance’; Grimm/Stauberstahl state that 1.2343 has ‘higher toughness than 1.2344’.​‌​​‌​
X40CrMoV5-1 / 1.2344 (EN ISO 4957)T20813 (the AISI H13 counterpart)​‌​​‌​1.23440.35-0.42% (SteelNumber and Otai agree) – INSIDE the ASTM H13 band (0.32-0.45%) but NARROWER than it​‌​​‌​4.80-5.50%1.20-1.50% (SteelNumber) · 1.10-1.50% (Otai) – THE SOURCES DIVERGE. The ASTM H13 ceiling is 1.75%, so the EN band is narrower.​‌​​‌​0.85-1.15% (SteelNumber, Otai and Virgamet agree) – NARROWER than the ASTM H13 band (0.80-1.20%)0.80-1.20%​‌​​‌​Dörrenberg gives 1020-1060 °C hardening and 500-550 °C tempering for 1.2344; the same producer gives 1000-1050 °C hardening and 500-550 °C tempering for 1.2343.Dörrenberg describes 1.2344 as offering ‘high strength at elevated temperatures, high hot wear resistance, good toughness’; the same producer describes 1.2343 as offering ‘excellent toughness combined with high thermal stability, high resistance to thermal shocks, good thermal conductivity’.​‌​​‌​1.2344 AND ASTM H13 ARE NOT WRITTEN AS EQUIVALENT: the EN band is narrower than the ASTM band on carbon, molybdenum and vanadium. Material certified to 1.2344 may satisfy an ASTM H13 order; THE REVERSE IS NOT ALWAYS TRUE.
​‌​​‌​

Additional information
Vanadium differenceTHE DECIDING DIFFERENCE IS VANADIUM. In the ASTM A681 band H11 carries 0.30-0.60% and H13 0.80-1.20%; in the EN ISO 4957 band 1.2343 carries 0.30-0.50% and 1.2344 0.85-1.15%. H13 therefore carries about TWICE the vanadium of H11. The producers’ nominal values point the same way: BÖHLER W300 (H11) 0.45% and 0.40%, BÖHLER W302 (H13) 0.95%; Dörrenberg 1.2343 0.40%, 1.2344 1.00%; Carpenter H11 0.45%. Vanadium forms hard, stable VC carbide: it raises wear resistance and tempering resistance and lowers toughness and thermal conductivity. IN PRACTICE: H11 is chosen where impact and thermal shock arrive together (forging dies, hot shear blades, large extrusion tooling, aerospace structure), and H13 where high volume die casting or wear governs. The chromium, molybdenum and silicon bands are almost identical in the two grades; the difference is therefore not ‘more alloyed versus less alloyed’ but a direct VANADIUM-FOR-TOUGHNESS TRADE.​‌​​‌​
Melting practice differenceTHERE IS A THIRD AXIS AND IT DOES NOT APPEAR IN THE TABLE: MELTING PRACTICE. None of the three columns imposes a melting practice; ASTM A681 and EN ISO 4957 give only chemistry and an annealed hardness ceiling. The REQUIREMENT asked for in aerospace work sits in AMS 6487: ‘Consumable Electrode Vacuum Re-Melted’ (CEVM/VAR) and ‘premium aircraft-quality’. On the producer side, ESR (electroslag remelting) is offered as a commercial upgrade (BGH 1.2343 ESR, ROVALMA 1.2343 ESR, Marks 1.2343 ESU, Schmolz + Bickenbach Thermodur 2343 EFS ‘extra fine structure’); BGH states that ‘best toughness properties, that match requirements of modern and filigree tools are achieved by electro slag remelting (ESR)’. ESR AND VAR ARE NOT THE SAME THING, and an ESR certificate does not satisfy the AMS 6487 requirement.​‌​​‌​
Ortak sinirALL THREE ARE HOT WORK TOOL STEELS AND NONE OF THEM IS STAINLESS. Five percent chromium does not form a passive layer. In all three the governing failure mechanism is thermal fatigue (heat checking); in all three a single temper is unacceptable; and in all three, if the quench rate is insufficient, grain boundary carbide precipitation and pearlite form and the Charpy value falls. Choosing the grade solves none of these three problems; it only moves the trade-off point between toughness and wear.​‌​​‌​
‘H13’ AND ‘1.2344’ ARE NOT TWO DIFFERENT STEELS; they are the same steel named in two standards. They are nevertheless shown as SEPARATE COLUMNS because their bands are not identical – acceptance is decided by looking at the heat analysis. THE TABLE DOES NOT COMPARE HARDNESS OR TENSILE FIGURES, because the maximum hardness the two grades can reach is similar (both are of the order of 54-56 HRC as quenched). The difference is not in the hardness but in how far up in temperature that hardness is held, and at what cost in toughness. The rating language of the BÖHLER W300 and W302 pages (good / high / very high) is ONE PRODUCER’S SINGLE SCALE, which is why it was used for the comparison. Ratings from different producers have NOT been placed side by side.

H11’s 5 % chromium is the number people get wrong most often. The stainless threshold is around 10.5 % Cr; H11 is at half of it. H11 is not stainless, is not corrosion resistant and does rust. The chromium is there for hardenability and hot strength, not for corrosion.​‌​​‌​

Where H11 Fails

Corrosion — none at all​‌​​‌​5 % Cr forms no passive film. H11 rusts in damp storage, inside water cooling channels and in salt environments. Corrosion inside the cooling channels of a water-cooled die is a real failure mechanism — and a corrosion pit is a starting point for heat checking. Water chemistry and channel cleanliness can matter more than the material choice
Wear resistance — the weak one in its class​‌​​‌​Vanadium at 0.30–0.60 % is about half of H13’s 0.80–1.20 %. With fewer MC-type vanadium carbides, abrasive and erosive wear resistance sits below H13’s. If the die is dying by wear, H11 is the wrong choice — go to H13, to a surface treatment, or to a coating
Above 600 °C — rapid softening​‌​​‌​The published table: 46 HRC at a 550 °C temper, 30 HRC at 650 °C. Sixteen HRC points in a hundred degrees. H11 is not a high-temperature alloy, and an application carrying continuous load above 600 °C belongs in the Hastelloy X, alloy 718 or Waspaloy class
Service temperature > tempering temperature​‌​​‌​The absolute rule, and the one most often broken. The part tempers itself in service; hardness falls, dimensions move, and there is no way back
Hydrogen embrittlement​‌​​‌​A real risk in structural H11 at the 1793 MPa level. Acid cleaning, electroplating and cathodic protection all charge hydrogen in. A post-plating hydrogen bake-out is mandatory in aerospace specifications
Letting a quenched part stand​‌​​‌​An H11 part that has come down to 50–70 °C and is then left untempered will crack on its own. That is not a material defect but a shop discipline problem — and it is the most common failure in H11
Slow quenching​‌​​‌​It passes the hardness test and breaks in service. Slow cooling precipitates carbides on the grain boundaries and destroys toughness; the hardness check will not show it. Every shop that treats hardness as the acceptance criterion falls into this trap
A single temper​‌​​‌​Once-tempered H11 contains untempered martensite. It is brittle and dimensionally unstable. Double tempering is not advice but a requirement

Frequently Asked Questions​‌​​‌​

Our die is dying from a heat-check network. Should we move from H13 to H11?

Check four things before you move; in most cases the problem is not the material.
1. Is the die being preheated? Shooting hot metal into a cold die produces the most severe thermal shock seen in the field and burns a substantial share of the die’s life in the first hundred shots. 2. Was the white layer removed from the EDM surfaces and was the part re-tempered? If that step was skipped, your die surface carries an untempered, brittle martensite layer under tensile stress, and the first cracks will start there. 3. Was the quench fast enough? A slowly cooled block passes the hardness test but is low in toughness — and toughness is heat-checking resistance. 4. Is there decarburization? Heat treating without a protective atmosphere leaves a soft surface layer, and thermal fatigue starts exactly there.
If all four are clean, the material discussion becomes meaningful. Classic tool-steel practice points to H11: halve the vanadium and the carbide volume fraction drops, fracture toughness rises, and the crack both starts later and runs slower. But let us be honest: some current commercial sources argue the exact opposite — that H13’s higher hot hardness makes it superior — and we could not find a peer-reviewed dataset measuring the two on the same rig.
Our suggestion points elsewhere: instead of going from H13 to classic H11, look at a MODIFIED H11. A silicon-reduced, VAR- or ESR-melted, premium-class 1.2343 derivative can deliver 80–100 J Charpy V at room temperature — against the 13.6–33.9 J published for classic H11. Three to seven times the toughness is a far bigger prize than half a point of vanadium. And the producer reports that this toughness lets the tool run at 2 HRC higher working hardness without loss of toughness, which limits the formation of thermal fatigue cracks. Upgrade the class, not the grade.​‌​​‌​

The heat treater’s report says 52 HRC and the die broke anyway. How?

Because hardness is NOT an acceptance criterion in H11. Toughness is, and hardness does not measure it.
There are at least three ways of arriving at the right hardness by the wrong route, and all three pass a hardness test:
1. Slow quenching. If cooling is too slow, carbides precipitate on the grain boundaries on the way down from austenite. The matrix still hardens — the hardness holds — but the grain boundaries have been weakened. Fracture then comes along the grain boundaries, without warning. That is exactly why the die-casting world imposes a minimum cooling rate.
2. A single temper. H11 carries appreciable retained austenite after quenching. The first temper destabilises it and, on cooling, converts it to fresh, untempered martensite. The part leaves the furnace carrying brittle, never-tempered martensite inside it — and its hardness reads correctly for exactly that reason. The second temper exists to temper that fresh martensite and cannot be skipped.
3. Austenitizing too high. At 1030–1040 °C hardness and hot strength rise, but the austenite grain coarsens and toughness falls. None of that appears on a hardness report.
And there is a fourth, very insidious possibility: the part may have been left standing at room temperature before tempering. As-quenched H11 must go to tempering immediately once it reaches 50–70 °C; left standing, it cracks on its own, and that crack can be too fine to see.
What to ask for: not a hardness report but (a) the cooling curve or a record of the minimum cooling rate, (b) the number of tempering cycles with the time and temperature of each, (c) confirmation that intermediate cooling went all the way to room temperature, (d) the austenitizing temperature and (e) a Charpy specimen where possible. Do not have a critical die treated by a heat treater who will not supply these.​‌​​‌​

Our aerospace customer wants AMS 6487 and we hold ASTM A681 H11. Can we use it?

No — and the reason comes in three layers.
First layer: the carbon band. In ASTM A681 H11 carbon is 0.33–0.43 %. In AMS 6487 it is 0.38–0.43 % — the upper half of that band only. If your material came in at 0.34 % carbon it is fully compliant with ASTM and outside AMS 6487. And that is not an academic detail: structural use targets strength above 260 ksi (1793 MPa), which cannot be reliably reached with carbon at the bottom of the band.
Second layer: the melt route. AMS 6487 says Consumable Electrode Vacuum Re-Melted — VAR is mandatory. ASTM A681 imposes no melt route at all. That condition governs more than the chemistry does: in a structural steel at the 1793 MPa level, an inclusion is a direct fatigue crack initiator and heat treatment cannot remove it.
Third layer: the inspection and traceability regime. Aerospace material arrives with heat number traceability, an inspection level and release documentation. A block on a die shop’s rack does not carry that chain, however identical its chemistry.
Watch the reverse direction too: AMS 6487 material can be used in place of ASTM A681 H11 (it is narrower and cleaner) — but doing so is almost always money wasted. An aluminium die casting die gains nothing from VAR melting; what it needs is NADCA-class cleanliness and verified toughness, not aerospace traceability. Keep the two worlds apart: AMS is for aerospace, NADCA is for tooling, and ASTM A681 is the common floor beneath both.​‌​​‌​

The price gap between H11 and H13 is small. Why not just always buy H13?

For most work you genuinely can — and most of the sector already does. H13 is the world standard for aluminium die casting, it has the widest availability, it sits at the centre of the NADCA acceptance criteria and its heat-treatment window is the best understood of any grade. For a job you do not know, the default should be H13.
There are four situations where you should specifically look for H11:
1. Very heavy section. As section grows, cooling rate falls and toughness gives way. Low-vanadium H11 is tougher than H13 at the same section. On large forging dies and heavy blocks H11 is still preferred.
2. Severe thermal shock and/or water cooling. Classic tool-steel practice points to H11 here, and one US source states explicitly for H11 that it “permits water cooling in service”.
3. The die is dying by breaking in one go. A large crack, a corner breaking out, a full separation — these are toughness failures, not wear failures, and the answer is to reduce H13’s vanadium, not to increase it.
4. Aerospace structural use. That sits outside this argument altogether: there the choice is not H13 but AMS 6487 H11, and it has no alternative.
Conversely, the case where you should NOT reach for H11 is just as clear: if the die is dying by wear (dimensional loss, rounded edges, erosive washout), H11’s lower vanadium takes you further in the wrong direction. The decision criterion is not the price gap but the way the die dies — and you read that off the surface of the die you just scrapped.​‌​​‌​

Common datasheet errors — check before you order

1. AMS 6485 and AMS 6488 listed as if still current. AMS 6485H was CANCELLED in October 2006; AMS 6488H in January 2008. The current H11 aerospace specification is AMS 6487 (rev. M, 2021). A datasheet listing those two has not been updated in at least fifteen years — treat everything else on it with the same suspicion.
2. The sentence “H11 and H13 are effectively the same steel”. WRONG. Vanadium is 0.30–0.60 % against 0.80–1.20 % — roughly double. That is the only difference and it changes the whole balance of wear, toughness and heat checking.
3. Thermal conductivity given as 42.2 W/m·K. It is an outlier. Two independent European producers publish 24.9–25 W/m·K at 20 °C. Do not use 42.2 — and it is a large enough error to double your die cooling calculation.
4. Publishing a single “tempering curve”. H11’s hardness–tempering curve shifts with the austenitizing temperature. One source puts the secondary hardening peak at about 400 °C; another shows a far flatter curve still at about 47 HRC at 600 °C. A tempering table that does not state the austenitizing temperature, the specimen diameter and the number of cycles is unusable.
5. Writing “double tempering is recommended”. It is not recommended, it is REQUIRED. The first temper converts retained austenite into fresh, untempered martensite; the second temper exists to temper it. On the aerospace route the number of cycles is THREE.
6. Conflating the stress-relief temperatures. Stress relief before hardening (350 °C up to 600–670 °C depending on the source) and stress relief after hardening (28–42 °C below the final tempering temperature) are not the same operation. Confusing them softens a hardened part.
7. Giving a single soft-annealing temperature. Published values scatter across 750–800, 800–810, 850 and 871 °C. Do not average them; follow the sheet of the producer you are actually buying from. The common acceptance criterion is the outcome: annealed hardness ≤229 HB.
8. Publishing a Charpy value without qualification. The band published for classic H11 is 13.6–33.9 J; for a modified/premium H11 it is about 80–100 J. Three to seven times. Without the hardness, the tempering temperature, the specimen orientation and the quality class, a toughness number is meaningless.
9. The sentence “it contains 5 % chromium, so it is corrosion resistant”. WRONG. The stainless threshold is around 10.5 % Cr. H11 rusts. The chromium is there for hardenability and hot strength.
10. Skipping the post-EDM step. The white (recast) layer must both be removed mechanically AND be followed by re-tempering. Doing one and skipping the other leaves half the damage in place.
11. Reading “air hardening” as “can be cooled slowly”. A dangerous misreading. H11 hardens in air, but slow cooling precipitates grain-boundary carbides and destroys toughness — and the hardness test will not show it.
12. Assuming it is harmless to let a quenched part stand. An H11 part that has reached 50–70 °C must go straight to tempering; left standing, it cracks on its own.
13. Treating ASTM A681 and AMS 6487 as equivalent. AMS 6487 narrows carbon to 0.38–0.43 % and mandates VAR. Every AMS 6487 is an A681 H11; not every A681 H11 is an AMS 6487.
14. Confusing the EN designation. The current EN name is X37CrMoV5-1. X38CrMoV5-1 circulates as an older or alternative designation; X40CrMoV5-1 is 1.2344, that is H13 — a completely different grade.
15. Mistaking a producer nominal for the standard band. Five producers, all selling “H11”, publish carbon between 0.36 and 0.40, silicon between 0.3 and 1.1 and vanadium between 0.40 and 0.50. In a die-life comparison, a claim of “the same material” without a producer name is meaningless.
16. Leaving the temperature claims unlabelled. 538 °C is a resistance-to-softening figure; 427–649 °C is a creep and rupture strength range; and the service temperature limit is whatever tempering temperature you chose. Three different numbers, three different meanings — label each one.​‌​​‌​

Related grades​‌​​‌​

300M  ·  AerMet 100  ·  AISI 4340  ·  Maraging 350  ·  All alloy steels →

​‌​​‌​

​‌​​‌​